Pyramid of Success Lesson Plan
Materials:
• colored pencils
• colored construction paper or colored cardstock
• scissors
• glue
1. Quickwrite
a. Have students to think about their definition of success.
b. Some questions you could ask:
• “How do you define success? Why is success important to you?”
• “Who are some of the successful people in your life? Why do you think they
are successful?
• “What makes a successful person?”
• “Who are some people you admire that are successful? Why do you admire
them?”
• “How does our society define success? Do you agree or disagree? Why?”
2. Think-Pair-Share
a. Give students time to write and have them share w/a partner or in a small group.
b. Have students share w/others they don’t know, etc. to get them up and moving.
3. Introduce John Wooden
a. Read the following quote and have students copy it down in their notes:
“Success is peace of mind, which is a direct result of self-satisfaction in
knowing you made the effort to do your best to become the best you
are capable of becoming.” (John Wooden)
b. Have students take some notes on who John Wooden is.
c. Here are some helpful links:
• http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Wooden
• http://www.achievement.org/autodoc/page/woo0bio-1
• http://www.uclabruins.com/sports/m-baskbl/spec-rel/ucla-woodenpage.
html
4. Show the TED.com talk that John Wooden gave. If your school blocks the TED.com site,
you can download the video from home (the download is of a much higher quality).
Here’s the link:
• http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/john_wooden_on_the_difference_between_wi
nning_and_success.html
• The video is about 20 minutes long.
5. Focused Note-taking
a. Students practice Focused-Note taking skills (based on the new materials from
AVID Center) as they watch John Wooden’s TED talk.
b. Let the video play all the way through in order to give the students practice taking
notes as if they are listening to a college lecture.
c. Be sure to give the students a purpose for taking notes—they are to take notes on
how John Wooden defines success and how he learned it.
d. After taking notes on the video, give students sufficient time to collaborate and
compare notes with others (Step 3: Review and revise notes) and to fill in any
gaps in their notes. You can also take notes on the video and have students
compare their notes with yours.
e. Also, give students at least 8 minutes to write their summary or learning log
reflection on their notes.
f. Students read their summaries to a partner.
6. Pass out the handout on Pyramid of Success blocks (Handout 1).
a. Talk to the students about building a pyramid and how the base and cornerstones
are the most important parts of the pyramid i.e. important to have a strong
foundation of values and traits.
b. Instruct students to first decorate each block before cutting them out.
c. Be creative on each block i.e. use designs, different colors for each block, etc.
Encourage students to go beyond using one solid color for each block.
d. Show examples of how to color each block.
e. After coloring each block, cut blocks out.
f. Students create their own personal Pyramid of Success, with “Personal Best” at
the top.
i. Glue the blocks on to the colored paper.
ii. Five blocks on the bottom make up the base and build up from there.
g. Students write an explanation on the back of the colored paper explaining why
they choose those traits as their base and cornerstones.
h. Post the students’ pyramids of success around the classroom.
7. Focused Note-taking on John Wooden’s Pyramid of Success.
a. Show the PowerPoint on John Wooden’s Pyramid of Success.
b. Students use the blank Pyramid of Success to fill in.
c. Students copy the quotes on each building block and also any explanations you
choose to include for each block of the pyramid.
d. Show the video clip “John Wooden Quotes” to end the notes.
e. After taking notes on the PowerPoint, give students sufficient time to collaborate
and compare notes with others (Step 3: Review and revise notes) and to fill in any
gaps in their notes.
f. Also, give students at least 8 minutes to write their summary or learning log
reflection on their notes.
g. Students read their summaries to a partner.
Monday, February 13, 2012
Internship and IPOL Information
Sample Internship Intro:
Good Afternoon,
Our school internship program has several exceptional candidates that are interested in developing a community service internship project with your company. This would be an incredible learning/outreach project for everyone involved and we would enjoy the opportunity to speak with you more about the possibilities. Please feel free to contact me with any questions at: steve.smith@riverspringscharter.org
Our students, families and staff appreciate your support and we look forward to working with you.
Sincerely,
Steve Smith
Internship Advisor / Entrepreneurship and Technology Instructor
River Springs Charter School – Temecula
Temecula 24 Hour Urgent Care
Phone - (951) 795-4923
Fax - (951) 506-0992
41715 Winchester Road - Suite 101
Temecula, California 92590
Fax - (951) 506-0992
41715 Winchester Road - Suite 101
Temecula, California 92590
Internship Project Description
This form is designed for students and mentors to work together to create a meaningful project that contributes to the internship site. Some sites might choose to have the students complete a few smaller projects and some might focus on one larger one. Either way is fine as long as each intern ends their internship experience with a tangible product(s) that they
developed or helped to create. It is important that the project drive the student’s experience rather than the site itself. It is the work that is done at their internship sites that will make the time spent there meaningful and therefore projects/activities must be planned out according to the intern’s interests and abilities. Each intern will be required to present their project at their work site. Interns will present to their mentor, their colleagues, a RSCS staff member, and a small group of RSCS students. Two sample projects are described at the end of this packet.
Intern Name_____________________________________
Site Name_______________________________________
Mentor__________________________________________
Mentor Signature________________________________
I. With your mentor, answer the following questions in order to begin
brain-storming ideas for your internship project:
1. What skills (academic, creative, technical) would your intern like to
develop while at your site? (Be specific)
2. What interests do you have in regards to the work that is done at your
internship site?
3. What needs of the internship site/mentor can you address based on your skills and interests?
II. When designing project ideas with your mentor it is important to answer “yes” to the
following questions:
1. Will this project/projects take 3 weeks to complete?
2. Will you be required to use academic, creative, and/or technical skills?
3. Will you be required to learn something new?
4. Will the final product benefit the organization?
5. Will you be able to present your project to your colleagues at the end of your internship?
III. Site Project Description:
Use the information above to develop a project idea.
Internship site:____________________________________________
Department:______________________________________________
Project Description:
Title:___________________________
General Description:
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
Estimated time for completion:_____________________
Creative, Academic, and/or technical skills that will be utilized:
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
Learning objective: (What will be learned?)
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
Organization benefits: (How will this benefit your site?)
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
Intern Presentation of Learning:
Sit down with your mentor to create a plan for presenting and demonstrating your successes and projects this semester. You will need to present in a professional setting with your colleagues and/or other professionals at the end of your internship. The date for this presentation is _________.
Plan/ideas for presentation:
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
1. San Diego Ocean Foundation
Interns at San Diego Ocean Foundation will spend time learning about the White Sea Bass Restocking Project, Canyon Watch, and Storm Drain Stenciling programs (training provided), as well as assist with multiple aspects of our Coastal Cleanup Day and our annual Oceans Benefit Gala. After interns become familiar with the programs and the foundation,
the project will be to research, plan, prepare and host a volunteer event to promote ocean stewardship. Interns will choose the topic and type of project. Past interns planned, fundraised and advertised for a Storm Drain Stenciling Day for students at RDVD. Interns also researched and produced a public service announcement on the effects of Storm Drain Pollution.
2. San Diego State Communication Lab
Interns at the San Diego State Communication Lab will research the location and accessibility of fiber-optic infrastructure around the San Diego Harbor and help design a network that would enable ultra-high bandwidth applications such as digital cinema, immersive virtual realities, common operating pictures for humanitarian
assistance and disaster response globally, and collaborative interaction with other groups locally (SDSU, UCSD, Port of San Diego, County of EOC, and others) and international connections to places such as Indonesia, China, Mexico, Canada, and Africa. A professional presentation of the results of the research and demonstrations of possible capabilities will be part of the deliverables for the project.
iPOLs Internship Expectations
(General Expectations)
Presentations should take place last day of internship.
Presentations should be in front of your mentor, a panel of their choosing and the RSCS visitors.
Dress professionally. Even if you are in a casual environment, please dress appropriately for your presentation.
Maintain proper volume and eye contact.
Provide artifacts (photographs, material objects, or digital examples) that reflect the work and projects completed during the internship.
Your presentation should last 10 minutes. There will be a 10-minute question and answer period to follow.
Topics students should address during presentation:
Describe the activities, responsibilities and duties you completed during your internship.
Describe your project, discuss the steps you took to complete it and explain the project’s usefulness for your organization.
Describe what you learned in general about experiencing the professional working world.
Describe the skill sets that you possessed prior to your internship that were helpful to your site. How did you use them at your internship?
Describe skill sets that you acquired during your internship.
Provide an example of the importance of workplace communication. How did communicating with your mentor and coworkers help your performance?
Provide an example demonstrating the importance of mentorship. How did working closely with your mentor help your understanding of work, school, or your future?
Question and Answer topics to address during presentation:
Be prepared to answer questions about your site’s organization and purpose.
Consider the learning you accomplished during your internship, the role of school in preparing you for work and choices you will make later in life.
See the Suggested iPOL Questions on back.
Suggested iPOL Questions
Site Knowledge / Work & Project
What can you tell us about your work site? What organization does it have? What is the purpose of your site?
What did you learn from completing this internship?
How did you make a meaningful contribution to your workplace?
How did your project go from an idea or inspiration to a final product?
What did you learn about the quality and quantity of your own work?
What qualities or characteristics did you see in your coworkers that you would like to develop in yourself?
Work & School Reflection
How well did school prepare you for your internship experience? What helpful skills and knowledge did you bring?
In what areas could school have better prepared you for your internship? What could you have done better?
How was your work as an intern meaningful to your education? What did it tell you about school?
How was your work significant or meaningful to the world beyond school and your specific internship site?
Work & Life Reflection
What new appreciations did you develop while working as an intern? How so?
How did interpersonal relationships or collaboration influence your views?
How did your view of life beyond high school change or develop during your time as an intern?
What new questions has your internship inspired you to ask about our world?
How might internship influence the direction of your life?
School-to-Work Reflection
In 1994, the U.S. Congress passed the School-to-Work Opportunities Act in an effort to re-establish the benefit that high school students have in learning that comes from being situated in an adult workplace environment. Research has found that these experiences offer students a chance to reflect on the role of work in their life and in society. It also has been found to increase students’ interest in attending and completing college.
How did the School-to-Work Opportunities Act benefit you this semester?
“6 A’s of Project Based Learning”
Does the project emanate from a problem that has meaning to the student?
Is it a problem or question that might actually be tackled by an adult at work or in the community?
Do students create or produce something that has personal and/or social value, beyond the school setting?
Academic Rigor
Does the project lead students to acquire and apply knowledge central to one or more discipline or content areas?
Does it challenge students to use methods of inquiry central to one or more disciplines? (e.g., to think like a scientist)
Do students develop higher order thinking skills and habits of mind? (e.g., searching for evidence, taking different perspectives)?
Applied Learning
Does the learning take place in the context of a semi-structured problem, grounded in life and work in the world beyond school?
Does the project lead students to acquire and use competencies expected in high performance work organizations (e.g., teamwork, appropriate use of technology, problem solving and communication)?
Does the work require students to develop organizational and self-management skills?
Active Exploration
Do students spend significant amounts of time doing field-based work?
Does the project require students to engage in real investigations, using a variety of methods, media, and sources?
Are students expected to communicate what they are learning through presentation and/or performance?
Do students meet and observe adults with relevant expertise and experience?
Do students have an opportunity to work closely with at least one adult?
Do adults collaborate on the design and assessment of student work?
Assessment
Do students reflect regularly on their learning using clear project criteria that they have helped to set?
Do adults from outside the classroom help students develop a sense of real world standards for this type of work?
Will there be opportunities for regular assessment of student work through a range of methods, including exhibitions and portfolios
Consultancy Protocol, adapted for projects Adapted from Gene Thompson-Grove, National School Reform Faculty (NSRF) Purpose: A consultancy is a structured process for helping an individual or a team to think more expansively about a particular plan or concrete issue. Time: Approximately 50 minutes Roles: Presenter (whose work is being discussed by the group) Facilitator (who sometimes participates, depending on the group size) Steps: 1. Presentation (5-10 minutes), including, perhaps:
OR The presenter gives an overview of the dilemma/issue with which s/he is struggling, and frames a question for the consultancy group to consider. The framing of this question, as well as the quality of the presenter’s reflection on the plan/issue being discussed, are key features of this protocol. If the presenter has brought student work, educator work, or other “artifacts,” there is a pause here to silently examine the work/documents. The focus of the group’s conversation is on the dilemma. 2. The consultancy group asks clarifying questions of the presenter—that is, questions that have brief, factual answers. (5 minutes) 3. The group asks probing questions of the presenter. These questions should be worded so that they help the presenter clarify and expand his/her thinking about the plan/issue presented to the consultancy group. The goal here is for the presenter to learn more about the project/issue s/he framed or to do some analysis of the plan/issue presented. The presenter may respond to the group’s questions, but there is no discussion by the consultancy group of the presenter’s responses. At the end of the ten minutes, the facilitator asks the presenter to re-state his/her question for the group (for dilemma only). (10 minutes) 4. The group talks with each other about the plan/issue presented. (15 minutes) Possible questions to frame the discussion: What did we hear? What didn’t we hear that we think might be relevant? What assumptions seem to be operating? What questions does the plan/issue raise for us? What do we think about the plan/issue? What might we do, or what have we done in similar situations? Members of the group sometimes suggest refinements/solutions to the plan/issue. Most often, however, they work to define the issues more thoroughly and objectively. The presenter doesn’t speak during this discussion, but instead listens and takes notes. 5. The presenter reflects on what s/he heard and on what s/he is now thinking, sharing with the group anything that particularly resonated for him or her during any part of the consultancy. (5 minutes) 6. The facilitator leads a brief conversation about the group’s observation of the consultancy process. (5 minutes) Some Tips (Dilemma Consultancy) Step 1: The success of the consultancy often depends on the quality of the presenter’s reflection in Step 1 as well as on the quality and authenticity of the question framed for the consultancy group. However, it is not uncommon for the presenter at the end of a consultancy to say, “Now I know what my real question is.” That is fine, too. It is sometimes helpful for the presenter to prepare ahead of time a brief (one-two page) written description of the plan/issue and the issues related to it for the consultancy group to read as part of Step 1. Step 2: Clarifying questions are for the person asking them. They ask the presenter “who, what, where, when, and how.” These are not “why” questions. They can be answered quickly and succinctly, often with a phrase or two. Step 3: Probing questions are for the person answering them. They ask the presenter “why” (among other things), and are open-ended. They take longer to answer, and often require deep thought on the part of the presenter before s/he speaks. Step 4: When the group talks while the presenter listens, it is helpful for the presenter to pull his/her chair back slightly away from the group. This protocol asks the consultancy group to talk about the presenter in the third person, almost as if s/he is not there. As awkward as this may feel at first, it often opens up a rich conversation, and it gives the presenter an opportunity to listen and take notes, without having to respond to the group in any way. Remember that it is the group’s job to offer an analysis of the plan/issue or question presented. It is not necessary to solve the plan/issue or to offer a definitive answer. It is important for the presenter to listen in a non-defensive manner. Listen for new ideas, perspectives, and approaches. Listen to the group’s analysis of your question/issues. Listen for assumptions—both your own and the group’s—implicit in the conversation. Don’t listen for judgment of you by the group. This is not supposed to be about you, but about a question you have raised. Remember that you asked the group to help you with this plan/issue. Step 5: The point of this time period is not for the presenter to give a “blow by blow” response to the group’s conversation, nor is it to defend or further explain. Rather, this is a time for the presenter to talk about what were, for him/her, the most significant comments, ideas and questions s/he heard. The presenter can also share any new thoughts or questions s/he had while listening to the consultancy group. Step 6: Debriefing the process is key. Don’t short-change this step. Presentation of Learning What is a POL? This is a 7-10 minute presentation given to your peers on a project that you have completed over the past few weeks. Can we use technology? You can use technology in your presentation and try to use 3 mediums during your presentation. Check with your teacher about the appropriate use of media if you are unsure about the content. When do we work on this? We will give you a portion of the class period to present. During this time you should work on putting together a POL OUTLINE for the project you are presenting to your peers. You can present your POL on a Tri-fold board or some other type of visual display. We encourage students to bring in visual aids to help explain their project. Here is what should be included in your POL OUTLINE. 1. Introduction · Name · Grade · Class Period 2. Project description - this should be a general and broad synopsis of your project. Using as few words as possible to describe what you did. (This must be less than 3 sentences with no bullet points) 3. Requirements - more specific. What did you have to do? What did you have to turn in? What was required to complete the project? Use bullet points. 4. Steps- this is the most specific. Go in order of what steps you needed to take to complete each requirement. Use bullets. Use words like: first, next, after, then, eventually, finally, etc. 5. Skills you learned - do some soul searching. If you did something that you haven’t done before, chances are that you learned something. What was it? Try to put it into words. Use bullets. 6. Reflection - Use bullet points to list challenges, successes, surprises, etc. 7. Interactive Activity – create an activity/lesson/game that will engage your audience. This could be a quiz on your POL, or a small lesson. For example, last year I had a student in a Sign Language POL and she had us all learn our names in Sign language. |
Wednesday, October 19, 2011
This is not a threat... But just in case...
Blake Host,
Remember when you would tease me in the 1st, 2nd, 3rd grades? Well I'm back in Palo Alto. And I grew out of my "fat chicken" appearance. I'm over 5' 4", can bench press over 150 lbs. and can climb a a 35 ft. tree in 5 minutes. This is not a threat... But if you tease me again in class... YOU'LL REGRET IT!!!!!!!!!
Remember when you would tease me in the 1st, 2nd, 3rd grades? Well I'm back in Palo Alto. And I grew out of my "fat chicken" appearance. I'm over 5' 4", can bench press over 150 lbs. and can climb a a 35 ft. tree in 5 minutes. This is not a threat... But if you tease me again in class... YOU'LL REGRET IT!!!!!!!!!
Wednesday, October 5, 2011
SLC's Information
Building a Student-Led Conference
Your Student Led Conference is a chance for you to show the process of your growth.
Areas of growth can include:
• Personal growth in the Habits of Heart and Mind (Cooperation, Refinement, Perspective, Mindfulness, Evidence, Perseverance, and Compassion).
• Academic Growth in Math and Science, Humanities, Electives
• Growth in the process of Design.
• Growth in the process of doing a project (show a “Project Process Flowchart”).
• Growth in the quality of work.
Math/Science
Find the following artifacts of work:
1. Academic growth in Math: Find one or two (or more) artifacts of your work in Math that shows how you went from struggling on an objective (scoring less than 80%) to finally passing that objective.
2. Quality of work: Find one or two artifacts of how your work has improved in quality. Examples can be from Warm-ups, Problems of the Week or Homework examples.
a. You must include drafts of your projects like design drawings or writing rough drafts (Fermi Power Points, Snipe Trap and Humpty Dumpty Jumps projects, etc.)
3. Design: Find one or two artifacts of your learning of the design process.
a. Show and explain a “Project Process Flowchart”.
b. Show your schematics or 3-View Drawing of:
• Practice Drawing
• Personal item drawing
• Humpty Dumpty JUMPS “Drop Box” drawing.
4. Construction: Use pictures/videos from a project or physical evidence from classwork, show what tools and construction techniques (safety, tools, etc.) you have learned to use.
5. Claim-Evidence-Reasoning (CER) Snipe Trap paper: Show your drafts and all of the “work” THEN show digital documents of your FINISHED work.
Humanities
Find the following artifacts of work:
1. Academic growth in Reading: Find one or two (or more) artifacts of your work in Accelerated Reading that shows proficiency in reading comprehension and/or vocabulary.
2. Academic growth in understanding new concepts: Find your final exam from a Project.
3. Quality of work: Find one or two artifacts of how your work has improved in quality. Examples can be from a Project (photographs or narratives), QuickWrites, or Journal entries.
4. Writing and Refinement: Drafts of cases from Debate Project or of narratives from a Project.
5. Critical Thinking or Logic: Find a blog post/written document and compare debate cases from a project.
SLC Presentation
To write your speech:
- Select 2-3 artifacts per class to demonstrate process of learning
- Organize presentation with 1 or 2 arguments per class, use C.E.R.
Example Introduction: Welcome to my SLC. In this conference, I would like to share with you some artifacts to show the process of my learning. First, I am going to talk about my ________________ class. Second, I will talk about my ____________________ class, and finally, I will talk about my ______________________ class.
Humanities:
Claim: I grew in_______________________.
Evidence: Explain artifacts.
Reasoning: Therefore, you can see with this artifact that I grew in ____________________.
Math/Physics:
Claim: I grew in_______________________.
Evidence: Explain artifacts.
Reasoning: Therefore, you can see with this artifact that I grew in ____________________.
Electives:
Claim: I grew in_______________________.
Evidence: Explain artifacts.
Reasoning: Therefore, you can see with this artifact that I grew in ____________________.
Example Conclusion: In conclusion, I feel that I have grown in ___________________, __________________, and _______________________ because ______________________.
Do you have any questions?
Thursday, August 25, 2011
Sunday, August 21, 2011
Wednesday, August 3, 2011
Socratic Seminar 101
Sample 1:
Currency Knowledge
Subjects: Math, Humanities, Computer Science
Grade Level: 7th
Duration: (3) 5 minute lessons
School: RSCS
Project Details
· Title: Currency Knowledge
· Author: Steve Smith
· Content Area: Math, Humanities, Computer Science
· Essential Question: How does currency affect your household, your peers, and your community
Summary: Currency Knowledge is designed for any level of school instruction. This interdisciplinary unit will engage each student with standard knowledge of currency. The class will create and design one written question about money. The students derive this question from playing a observation game called “Pass the Buck”.
Every student will pass around a dollar coin, a dollar bill, or some denomination of currency. The questions that are created from this observation will be put into a Socratic session of discussion. From this Socratic seminar, they will finish the unit off by playing a game of jeopardy to complete the learning of currency
What Will Students Be Able To Do:
§ The students will be analyzing how currency is made and produced. They will be writing questions about this topic and honing their thoughts and opinions about currency.
§ Each student will be working with linguistic and analytical methods of learning.
§ Students will lead a Socratic session of discussion and derive information from their peers.
§ The class will also learn how to create a PowerPoint that\ can be produced in a game format.
What Will Students Know:
§ The history of currency and how currency is produced.
Student Deliverables:
§ Written questions and answers based on their knowledge of currency
§ Completed rubric for Socratic seminar
Project Documents:
§ Various forms of currency
§ Rubric for Socratic Seminar
§ Jeopardy PowerPoint Presentation
English-language Arts Content Standards: Seventh Grade
Vocabulary and Concept Development
1.2 Use knowledge of Greek, Latin, and Anglo-Saxon roots and affixes to understand content-area vocabulary.
1.3 Clarify word meanings through the use of definition, example, restatement, or contrast.
Comprehension
1.1 Ask probing questions to elicit information, including evidence to support the speaker's claims and conclusions.
1.2 Determine the speaker's attitude toward the subject.
1.3 Respond to persuasive messages with questions, challenges, or affirmations.
Organization and Delivery of Oral Communication
1.4 Organize information to achieve particular purposes and to appeal to the background and interests of the audience.
1.5 Arrange supporting details, reasons, descriptions, and examples effectively and persuasively in relation to the audience.
1.6 Use speaking techniques, including voice modulation, inflection, tempo, enunciation, and eye contact, for effective presentations.
Analysis and Evaluation of Oral and Media Communications
1.7 Provide constructive feedback to speakers concerning the coherence and logic of a speech's content and delivery and its overall impact upon the listener.
1.8 Analyze the effect on the viewer of images, text, and sound in electronic journalism; identify the techniques used to achieve the effects in each instance studied.
Sample 2:
1. WRITE DOWN A QUESTION
ABOUT THE “LEARNING PYRAMID”
(Then pass it to a friend and remember…spelling doesn’t count!)
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
"The unexamined life is not worth living." -Socrates
The Socratic method of teaching is based on Socrates' theory that it is more important to enable students to think for themselves than to merely fill their heads with "right" answers. Therefore, he regularly engaged his pupils in dialogues by responding to their questions with questions, instead of answers. This process encourages divergent thinking rather than convergent.
Students are given opportunities to "examine" a common piece of text, whether it is in the form of a novel, poem, art print, or piece of music. After "reading" the common text "like a love letter", open-ended questions are posed.
Open-ended questions allow students to think critically, analyze multiple meanings in text, and express ideas with clarity and confidence. After all, there is a certain degree of emotional safety felt by participants when they understand that this format is based on dialogue and not discussion/debate.
Dialogue is exploratory and involves the suspension of biases and prejudices. Discussion/debate is a transfer of information designed to win an argument and bring closure. Americans are great at discussion/debate. We do not dialogue well. However, once teachers and students learn to dialogue, they find that the ability to ask meaningful questions that stimulate thoughtful interchanges of ideas is more important than "the answer."
Participants in a Socratic Seminar respond to one another with respect by carefully listening instead of interrupting. Students are encouraged to "paraphrase" essential elements of another's ideas before responding, either in support of or in disagreement. Members of the dialogue look each other in the "eyes" and use each other names. This simple act of socialization reinforces appropriate behaviors and promotes team building.
Dialogue is characterized by:
* suspending judgment
* examining our own work without defensiveness
* exposing our reasoning and looking for limits to it
* communicating our underlying assumptions
* exploring viewpoints more broadly and deeply
* being open to disconfirming data
* approaching someone who sees a problem differently not as an adversary, but as a colleague in common pursuit of better solution.
What is the difference between dialogue and debate?
* Dialogue is collaborative: multiple-sides work toward shared understanding.
Debate is oppositional: two opposing sides try to prove each other wrong.
* In dialogue, one listens to understand, to make meaning, and to find common ground.
In debate, one listens to find flaws, to spot differences, and to counter arguments.
* Dialogue enlarges and possibly changes a participant's point of view.
Debate defends assumptions as truth.
* Dialogue creates an open-minded attitude: openness to being wrong and an openness to change.
Debate creates a close-minded attitude, a determination to be right.
* In dialogue, one submits one's best thinking, expecting that other people's reflections will help improve it rather than threaten it.
In debate, one submits one's best thinking and defends it against challenge to show that it is right.
* Dialogue calls for temporarily suspending one's beliefs.
Debate calls for investing wholeheartedly in one's beliefs.
* In dialogue, one searches for strengths in all positions.
In debate, one searches for weaknesses in the other position.
* Dialogue respects all the other participants and seeks not to alienate or offend.
Debate rebuts contrary positions and may belittle or deprecate other participants.
* Dialogue assumes that many people have pieces of answers and that cooperation can lead to a greater understanding.
Debate assumes a single right answer that somebody already has.
* Dialogue remains open-ended.
Debate demands a conclusion.
Guidelines / Expectations for Participants in a Socratic Seminar
1. Refer to the text when needed during the discussion. A seminar is not a test of memory. You are not "learning a subject"; your goal is to understand the ideas, issues, and values reflected in the text.
2. It's OK to "pass" when asked to contribute.
3. Do not participate if you are not prepared. A seminar should not be a bull session.
4. Do not stay confused; ask for clarification.
5. Stick to the point currently under discussion; make notes about ideas you want to come back to.
6. Don't raise hands; take turns speaking.
7. Listen carefully.
8. Speak up so that all can hear you.
9. Talk to each other, not just to the leader or teacher.
10. Discuss ideas rather than each other's opinions.
11. You are responsible for the seminar, even if you don't know it or admit it.
When I am evaluating your Socratic Seminar participation, I ask the following questions about participants. Did they….
Speak loudly and clearly?
Cite reasons and evidence for their statements?
Use the text to find support?
Listen to others respectfully?
Stick with the subject?
Talk to each other, not just to the leader?
Paraphrase accurately?
Ask for help to clear up confusion?
Support each other and avoid hostile exchanges?
Question others in a civil manner?
Seem prepared?
Pre-Seminar Question-Writing:
Before you come to a Socratic Seminar class, please read the assigned text (novel section, poem, essay, article, etc.) and write at least one question in each of the following categories:
WORLD CONNECTION QUESTION:
Write a question connecting the text to the real world.
Example: If you were given only 24 hours to pack your most precious belongings in a backpack and to get ready to leave your hometown, what might you pack? (After reading the first 30 pages of NIGHT).
CLOSE-ENDED QUESTION:
Write a question about the text that will help everyone in the class come to an agreement about events or characters in the text. This question usually has a "correct" answer.
Example: What happened to Hester Pyrnne's husband that she was left alone in Boston without family? (After the first 4 chapters of “THE SCARLET LETTER”).
OPEN-ENDED QUESTION:
Write an insightful question about the text that will require proof and group discussion and "construction of logic" to discover or explore the answer to the question.
Example: Why did Gene hesitate to reveal the truth about the accident to Finny that first day in the infirmary? (After mid-point of A SEPARATE PEACE).
UNIVERSAL THEME/ CORE QUESTION:
Write a question dealing with a theme(s) of the text that will encourage group discussion about the universality of the text.
Example: After reading John Gardner's GRENDEL, can you pick out its existential elements?
LITERARY ANALYSIS QUESTION: Write a question dealing with HOW an author chose to compose a literary piece. How did the author manipulate point of view, characterization, poetic form, archetypal hero patterns, for example?
Example: In MAMA FLORA'S FAMILY, why is it important that the story is told through flashback?
THAT DESCRIBES WHAT YOU SEE
(Then pass it to a friend and remember…spelling still doesn’t count!)
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



